A community forum for the discussion of progressive ideas


Vol. 2, Num. 11

November 2001

Free -- Donations appreciated


‘Professor of the Year’ a convicted felon

By Dan Frazier
Tea Party Editor

In September, Flagstaff Tea Party reported that William Randolph Rhoton, a former Northern Arizona University professor who was named “Arizona Professor of the Year” in 1998, claimed to hold a degree from a Russian art academy that some say never existed. Rhoton was later caught up in a grade-change scandal and left NAU for reasons that are not entirely clear. Meanwhile, during the same period, former NAU president Clara Lovett stepped down, possibly because she feared that Rhoton’s questionable credentials would come to light during the investigation of the grade-change scandal. The full story is available at www.flagteaparty.org.

Now, new information has come to light that casts further doubt on the appropriateness of Rhoton’s Professor of the Year award. Based on tips from additional sources, and research at the Coconino County Superior Court, FTP has learned that Rhoton was indicted by a grand jury in April of 1987 on 15 felony counts of theft and burglary. The series of crimes took place between June of 1986 and March of 1987. At the time of his indictment, Rhoton was a 33-year-old juvenile counselor.

Nine counts against Rhoton were ultimately dismissed. However, on Jan. 21, 1988 Rhoton was convicted on six of the counts against him, including burglarizing an American Red Cross office, illegally entering and attempting to burglarize the offices of the U.S.G.S, and stealing tools, camera equipment, binoculars, and more from Wupatki National Monument. Rhoton was also convicted of stealing a semi-automatic pistol, camping equipment and a boat from other nonresidential locations. He was sentenced to a year in the county jail and four years of intensive probation. He apparently served his full jail sentence. He was also ordered to pay $4,030 in restitution and a $600 fine.

Several of the crimes that Rhoton was accused of took place in offices located in the Fourth Street Professional Building. Rhoton’s father, Nelo, had been the landlord of the building. Nelo died in August 1987 after being hit by a car, just a few months after his son’s crime spree apparently ended. At the time, Nelo  was in poor health and was having legal troubles of his own. Nelo had been indicted by a Coconino County grand jury in September 1986 on 44 counts of fraudulent schemes stemming from his work as an insurance salesman. Nelo allegedly defrauded his insurance customers out of more than $3 million. Earlier in his life, Nelo had been the president of the Flagstaff Chamber of Commerce, and the president of the Flagstaff stake of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.

Though his father’s criminal case was covered even in the Arizona Republic, Rhoton’s own indictment and subsequent trial appears to have received minimal press coverage. It may well be that Clara Lovett was unaware of Rhoton’s criminal record when she named him Arizona Professor of the Year.

Today, William Randolph Rhoton lives in Duluth, Minn., where he works as the director of the St. Luke’s Foundation. According to the foundation’s Web site, “the mission of St. Luke’s Foundation is to provide financial support that advances the goals and objectives of St. Luke’s Hospital. …” Rhoton is listed as the person people should contact if they wish to make a donation to the nonprofit foundation.